I eventually decided against it after realizing I’ll have to create a wiki, profile pages, a forum and a content manager all in one, all by myself. Unfortunately, not a great job to do on your own. I have however been working on redoing dushkin.org.

First of all, I have some friends on RP realms. So when I want to talk to them, I don’t want to talk through my character. Sometimes I just want to chat with the people. Is there something so wrong with that?

Not much. I do (did) the same myself in the appropriate channels – ones where the participants agreed are out of character. Whispers, custom channels, etc.

Second, you contradicted yourself, or so that’s the way I see it. You complain about not being able to kill people, then you go on to complain about how there are “No consequences?” Last time I checked, murder has consequences.

Yes, there are no consequences and that is my point. Murder is a consequence when it actually happens and is carried out in a manner befitting murder/death in general namely that you do not get back up. Resurrection is not very easy as the game makes it look. I am not contradicting myself.

I actually put a lot of thought into each character I make. I consider their personality, appearance, history, etc. I’m not going to put all this work into a character just to have it killed by some attention-starved, twelve year old idiot.

Yet another issue that I understand, there are far too many annoying kids in this game. For the single most popular MMOG in the industry, it is actually not as bad as it would seem. Still, those do occur on roleplaying realms. My tip is to not roleplay with them, much like how I avoid the DotA crowd. (Not a bad game, but a terrible community).

At the end of the day we agree, really. And I enjoy both RP in WoW as well as the game. But this is a piece that discusses the “dark” side of roleplaying as it stands. I look forward to coming back to it soon™ when Cataclysm hits (or a little before that).

First of all, I have some friends on RP realms. So when I want to talk to them, I don’t want to talk through my character. Sometimes I just want to chat with the people. Is there something so wrong with that?

Second, you contradicted yourself, or so that’s the way I see it. You complain about not being able to kill people, then you go on to complain about how there are “No consequences?” Last time I checked, murder has consequences. I hate to sound like one of your “Carebear players” (Oh wait, no I don’t. Hunh), but I actually put a lot of thought into each character I make. I consider their personality, appearance, history, etc. I’m not going to put all this work into a character just to have it killed by some attention-starved, twelve year old idiot.

But on the other points, yes. WoW is very RP-unfriendly and griefers suck. But the gameplay is still fun, and if you can find the right people and use enough creativity, RP can be too.

Going out of character is the will of the player. Why not allow they to go out of character when they don’t feel like rping at that moment? Some people enjoy all aspects of the game. It seems to me that all -you- are looking for is a game simply for RP. Of course, World of Warcraft isn’t for you.

World of Warcraft RP. People enjoy being creative in their own way. If you think it is stupid, then oh well, that is your own opinion. If they are having fun with it, it doesn’t matter. It is a game. That is what it is meant for.

Security is funny like that.. and one would think they applied some better form of authentication (fingerprint/retina scan) that offers splendid accuracy and some form of automated sensors that will catch guns etcetera as per usual. But that shit about guard dogs and guns sounds plain silly.